How to Start a PATENT LICENSING

service package

Overview of Patent Licensing

Patent licensing is a legal agreement between the patent holder (licensor) and a company or individual (licensee) who wishes to use the patented technology, product, or design. This arrangement allows the licensee to manufacture, sell, or use the patented invention, generating income for both parties through royalties and returns over the course of the licensing period.

Through patent licensing, the patent holder can transfer or grant their rights to a third party for a specified duration, based on a mutual agreement. During this period, the licensee gains the rights to benefit from the patented intellectual property, including the ability to manufacture, use, and profit from the invention.

What are the Different Types of Patent Licensing?

Following are the different types of Patent Licensing:

Types of Patent Licensing

  1. Exclusive Licensing: In this licensing type, all Patent rights are transferred to the licensee. The licensee holds all the rights of the Patent holder, except for the ability to transfer the Patent to another party. The title of the Patent remains with the original owner, but the rights to use the Patent are fully granted to a single party. This type of licensing reduces the likelihood of infringement as the licensee has exclusive rights in the market.

  2. Non-Exclusive Licensing: This licensing allows the Patent owner to grant licenses to multiple companies. The licensee can exploit the innovation, but so can others who hold the same license for the same Patent. The licensor retains the right to exploit the Patent as well.

  3. Sub-Licensing: This occurs when the licensee grants a license to third parties, allowing them to use the patented product. Essentially, it is the licensee transferring part of their licensed rights to other entities.

  4. Compulsory Licensing: A government grants permission to individuals or organizations to produce, use, or sell a patented product without the consent of the Patent holder, typically for public benefit. This is most commonly seen in the pharmaceutical industry, where it can be applied under conditions outlined in Section 84 of the Patents Act, 1970.

  5. Cross Licensing: This involves an exchange of licenses between multiple innovators or organizations. This is particularly useful when one innovation relies on another to compete in the market, facilitating mutual use of each other's patents.

  6. Voluntary Licensing: Often applied to pharmaceutical patents, voluntary licensing allows Patent owners to grant licenses to other parties, either exclusively or non-exclusively, to manufacture, distribute, or sell a product. This can be done as an act of goodwill or for other strategic purposes, often leading to reduced prices for consumers.

  7. Carrot Licensing: This type of licensing is used as a marketing strategy when the potential licensee is not yet utilizing the patented invention. The Patent owner encourages the licensee by offering them insight into the potential benefits of licensing the Patent, which could lead to mutual gains.

  8. Stick Licensing: In contrast to Carrot Licensing, Stick Licensing is used when a potential licensee is already using the patented technology without permission. The Patent owner presents the option of obtaining a license or facing legal consequences for the infringement.

Each of these licensing strategies serves different purposes and can be used based on the specific goals and circumstances of the Patent owner and licensee.

Advantages of Patent Licensing

Here are some key advantages of Patent Licensing:

  1. Access to International Markets: Expanding production and distribution globally can be challenging for many companies. Patent Licensing helps overcome this by allowing other organizations to manufacture and sell patented products, enabling the innovation to reach international markets more easily.

  2. Competitive Advantage: Licensing a Patent to an established company with a large customer base allows the patented product to reach a broader market. This provides a significant edge over competitors, helping the product gain traction in the marketplace more effectively.

  3. Risk Transfer: Manufacturing and producing products involve considerable risks. Through Patent Licensing, the Patent owner can transfer the financial and operational risks of production to the licensee, reducing their own exposure.

  4. Time-Limited Agreement: Since licenses are granted for a specific period, the Patent holder retains their exclusive rights to the invention once the licensing term expires. This ensures that the owner maintains control over their innovation in the long run.

Disadvantages of Patent Licensing

Here are some potential drawbacks of Patent Licensing:

  1. Loss of Control: During the licensing period, the Patent holder transfers certain rights to the licensee. As a result, the holder may lose partial or full control over their invention, affecting their ability to make decisions regarding its use.

  2. Difficulty in Finding a Suitable Licensee: Identifying the right licensee can be time-consuming and challenging. It requires significant effort to find a reliable partner, and the success of the licensing agreement depends on establishing a well-structured and clear contract.

  3. Dependence on the Licensee’s Competence: The Patent holder is dependent on the licensee’s ability to successfully commercialize the product. If the licensee fails to manage quality or execute a proper strategy, the Patent holder risks losing control and potentially damaging the reputation of their invention.

Common Mistakes in Patent Licensing

Here are some frequent mistakes made during the Patent Licensing process:

  1. Choosing an Incompetent Licensee: In the rush for growth, some inventors fail to thoroughly vet the appropriate licensee for their product, leading them to grant licenses to parties lacking the necessary expertise. This often results in the failure of the invention, even though it could have succeeded in the international market with the right licensee.

  2. Using Patented Products Before Signing an Agreement: Some licensees begin using or selling the patented product or design before finalizing the Patent License Agreement, leading to Patent Infringement. Licensees must ensure that the agreement is signed before taking any action with the patented product.

  3. Unawareness of Liability: Patent holders may not fully understand their liability, even during the license period. Although the rights are transferred temporarily to the licensee, the licensor remains the actual owner of the patented invention and can still be held accountable.

  4. Incorrect Royalty Arrangements: Some Patent holders require advance royalties or set a minimum annual royalty without carefully considering the terms, which can lead to disputes or financial strain.

  5. Failure to Seek Legal Guidance: Patent Licensing can be complex, and filing a Patent application is already a challenging process. Without a skilled Patent lawyer conducting due diligence, licensors may risk their rights and profits.

What is the Patent Licensing Royalty Rate?

The royalty rate in Patent Licensing refers to the agreed-upon fee that the licensee pays to the patent holder every time the patented product or item is sold. This amount is typically expressed as a percentage of the gross or net profit. The rate generally varies between 0.1% and 25%, depending on the industry and the type of invention.

Difference Between Patent Licensing and Patent Assignment

Patent Assignment involves the transfer of all exclusive rights of the Patent from the original owner (assignor) to another party (assignee) permanently. This transfer is officially recorded in the Patent records. In an assignment, the assignee pays a lump sum to the assignor and thereafter retains the rights to profit from the patented innovation.

On the other hand, Patent Licensing is when the Patent owner grants permission to a third party to use or benefit from the patented invention for a specific period. This transfer of rights is temporary, and the licensee is required to pay royalties to the licensor for the entire duration of the licensing agreement.

Risks and Limitations of Patent Licensing

  1. Dependence on the Licensee’s Capabilities: When licensing your Patent, your success largely depends on the licensee’s skills, resources, and efforts in bringing your product to market. It is crucial to select the right licensee to ensure the innovation reaches its full potential.

  2. Potentially Lower Profitability: Patent Licensing may yield lower profits compared to manufacturing and selling the product yourself. Although self-production involves higher investment and risk, the returns could exceed expectations when you control the production process.

  3. Disadvantages of a Licensing Agreement: If the business performs well but the agreement doesn’t clearly define royalty sharing or further development, the inventor might end up at a disadvantage. It’s essential to ensure all terms and clauses are thoroughly reviewed and clearly outlined to avoid future losses.

  4. Additional Demands from the Licensee: Initially, the licensee may not request additional resources, but as development progresses, they may ask for further contributions or data. This can result in unexpected costs or delays. To avoid this, the agreement should clearly define the terms to prevent the licensee from making further demands.